TESTERPOST

TESTERPOST

Our Recommendation

Youth Villages is highly recommended. Its transition program for young adults leaving foster care, LifeSet, was tested in one of the largest randomized trials ever run for this population. From October 2010 to October 2012, more than 1,300 young people were assigned, at random, to either a program group, which was offered the Transitional Living program’s services, or to a control group. After one year the program reduced homelessness, improved mental health, and reduced intimate partner violence. Those are ultimate outcomes measured against a control group, for a population with few proven options.

The evaluation also reported what did not work, and Youth Villages responded. LifeSet did not improve education, social support, or criminal involvement, and statistically significant impacts in the education and criminal involvement domains did not emerge in Year 2, spurring Youth Villages’ ongoing efforts to strengthen its program offerings in these areas. Its in-home family program, Intercept, has two independent quasi-experimental studies, the more recent using data through 2020, showing fewer out-of-home placements and faster permanency.

Three limits deserve a donor’s attention. The ultimate outcome evidence comes from a single trial whose data was collected more than a decade ago, with no newer comparison since, so we give it half credit under our recency standard. The trial measured effects at 12 and 24 months, while some youth were still in the program, rather than after program completion, so it cannot show whether they last. And Youth Villages’ own follow-up figures have no comparison group.

A second randomized trial of LifeSet is underway in New Jersey, designed to test effects 12 months after participants finish the program. It will be important evidence about the model. But it tests LifeSet as delivered by New Jersey’s local provider agencies, not by Youth Villages, so under our standard it would not count as a measurement of Youth Villages’ own work.

Youth Villages' Fierce Certification score is 95/100 points based on our criteria:
✔ Has Ultimate Outcome Goals (20 pts)
✔ Measures Intermediate Outcomes (15 pts)
✔ Measures Ultimate Outcomes (20 pts)
◪ Measures Intermediate and/or Ultimate Counterfactual (15 pts)
✔ Shows Continual Learning & Adaptation (25 pts)

The Social Problem

When families cannot manage a child’s serious emotional or behavioral problems, the state often removes the child. Youth Villages notes that more than 435,000 children are growing up in foster homes; 120,000 have been permanently separated from their parents and are waiting for adoption; 20,000 will turn 18 and “age out” without family support.

Removal brings its own harms: instability, repeated moves, and the trauma of separation from parents and siblings. Young people who leave care at 18 face the steepest odds. Among children who “age out” of the system at 18 years of age, 25% are homeless, nearly 20% live in poverty, 45% don’t complete high school or earn a GED, and 50% are unemployed 18 months later. One study found that 59 percent of women and nearly 82 percent of men who had been in foster care had been arrested by age 26, and Youth Villages cites research that 42% have at least one child by age 23.

The deepest consequences are to wellbeing itself: poor mental health, partner violence, housing insecurity, isolation, and the loss of a family to grow up in.

The Solution

Youth Villages’ core belief is that a family does a better job of raising a child than the state. Its services keep children at home where possible and support young adults where family is absent.

Intercept is an intensive in-home program for families with children at risk of removal. Key features of the program include program intensity (meeting with families an average of three times weekly), low staff caseloads of 4 – 5 families, active 24/7 on-call structure, and structured weekly supervision and consultation from a licensed clinical expert. Youth Villages also delivers Multisystemic Therapy, and in its early years it became the first agency to use Multisystemic Therapy on a large scale outside of clinical trials.

LifeSet serves young adults leaving foster care, juvenile justice, or mental health systems, providing intensive, individualized, and clinically focused case management, support, and services. It costs about $50 a day to provide the intensive, comprehensive services in LifeSet, and the services last six to nine months.

Youth Villages also runs residential treatment, foster care, adoption, and specialized crisis services, and through New Allies it helps states redesign their child welfare systems. It licenses LifeSet and Intercept to partner agencies.

Mapped against a Theory of Change, Intercept’s chain is short: intensive in-home work leads to fewer removals, which keeps families intact. LifeSet’s chain runs from weekly clinical case management to employment, housing, and coping skills, and from there to stability and wellbeing. Both chains are measured against comparison groups at the intermediate stage, and LifeSet’s is also measured at the ultimate stage. The weakest links are education, social support, and justice involvement, where the LifeSet trial found no effect.

Key Outputs

  • Last fiscal year, Youth Villages’ 5,000 employees served more than 50,000 children and young adults in more than 120 locations in 30 states and the District of Columbia
  • Revenues of $483,465,306 and expenses of $453,777,399 in 2025, per Form 990 data; the Chronicle of Philanthropy cites a $548 million budget, which may include affiliates
  • Since 1999, LifeSet has helped nearly 35,000 young people, making it the largest program of its type in the United States, with more than 7,400 young people served through transition-age services in 2025
  • LifeSet operates in 21 states, and nearly 90 percent of its $81 million budget comes from government sources
  • Intercept reached more than 10,000 families in 13 states in 2021 and earned the “well-supported” rating from the Title IV-E Prevention Services Clearinghouse, one of only 12 models in the country with that rating
  • Blue Meridian Partners has committed $175.6 million to Youth Villages over nearly a decade
  • The MDRC evaluation estimated the gross cost per LifeSet participant at approximately $11,840 in 2015 dollars

Key Intermediate Outcomes

Placement prevention, with a counterfactual. Chapin Hall at the University of Chicago evaluated Intercept using Tennessee child welfare records, in a quasi-experimental design relying exclusively on administrative data. Children referred to Intercept had 53 percent lower odds of placement than a matched comparison group, and the effects appeared to be sustained up to one year after the intervention ended. A second study with a separate group of children referred between 2018 and 2020 found a 37 percent lower risk of placement. That replication on a non-overlapping, more recent population is why this evidence keeps full credit under our recency standard.

Permanency, with a counterfactual. For children already in care, Intercept raised the odds of achieving permanency by about 24 percent against a matched comparison group.

Earnings and economic wellbeing, with a counterfactual. LifeSet raised earnings by 17 percent and reduced material hardship in year 1. In year 2, it did not increase average earnings.

Education and justice involvement, with counterfactual nulls. The LifeSet trial found no significant effect on education or criminal involvement. Some measures of educational enrollment and crime, especially by the second year, were in the unfavorable direction, though none was statistically significant.

Youth Villages’ own follow-up, without a comparison group. Across all programs, for youth served more than 60 days in FY23 to FY25, 78.6 percent were living at home or independently one year after discharge, 97.9 percent were in school or employed, and 87.1 percent reported no trouble with the law. These figures depend on who answers the follow-up; in earlier reporting, the 24-month response rate was 49.7 percent.

Key Ultimate Outcomes

All three ultimate counterfactual results come from MDRC’s randomized trial of LifeSet in Tennessee, run with Professor Mark Courtney of the University of Chicago.

Housing security. LifeSet increased housing stability and economic wellbeing, including a 22 percent decrease in the likelihood of experiencing homelessness. Youth Villages’ own data for FY19 to FY21 show 94 percent of LifeSet participants living with family or independently, without a comparison group. This is the only ultimate outcome Youth Villages still measures directly.

Mental health. Participants had fewer mental health problems than the control group.

Freedom from partner violence. The program reduced intimate partner violence. Safety in one’s own relationships is valued in itself, not as a step toward something else.

How to read these results. MDRC described the effects as modest but meaningful. All three were measured at one year, while some participants were still in the program. Social support and physical health did not improve. No ultimate outcome has been measured with a comparison group for Intercept, Multisystemic Therapy, or residential care, which serve most of Youth Villages’ children.

Why these count at half value. All three ultimate counterfactual results rest on data collected between 2010 and 2013, and no later study of Youth Villages’ own programs has measured these outcomes against a comparison group. We still treat the trial as strong evidence. Its age means we cannot be confident the program produces the same effects today, with different staff, sites, and a model Youth Villages has since modified. Mental health and partner violence also have no recent measurement of any kind.

A note on newer evidence from partner agencies. The New Jersey trial, run by the Urban Institute with federal funding, will measure whether LifeSet improves wellbeing and the transition to adulthood, with an end date of December 31, 2026. All four local LifeSet provider agencies in New Jersey are included in the study, and Youth Villages licenses and supports their delivery of the model. Its results will tell donors whether the model works when others deliver it. Because those agencies, not Youth Villages, deliver the program, we will report the findings but will not count them as a measurement of Youth Villages’ own work.

Continual Learning & Adaptation

It changed its whole model after its own follow-up data proved it wrong. In the mid-1990s, when Youth Villages was entirely residential, it tracked former residents and found that those who had stayed in the program longest, or who were 18 when they left, fared the worst. That finding overturned the assumption that longer stays produced better results, and Youth Villages rebuilt itself around in-home services.

It created LifeSet from that same finding. In the late 1990s, Youth Villages noticed that older teens who had spent the most time in foster care had the worst outcomes, and it developed LifeSet in 1999 specifically to address their needs.

It responded to null results. After the LifeSet trial found no education or justice effects, Youth Villages set out to test modifications to the model, aiming to improve outcomes in the domains where the program had not yet produced positive impacts.

It adopts proven models. It brought in Multisystemic Therapy from the Medical University of South Carolina, and working with that university’s researchers required careful outcome measurement.

It built measurement into operations. Youth Villages has a 47-member research department, unusual for a nonprofit, with systems that give daily updates on the performance of programs and staff. Chapin Hall’s Fred Wulczyn describes its approach as changing what it does whenever it lacks evidence of making a difference.

It keeps testing. Intercept was replicated with a new population, and Youth Villages engaged with federal evaluators to identify a location suitable for a second rigorous LifeSet trial. That trial is designed to fix the original’s main weakness by measuring effects after youth complete the program.

It shares externally. MDRC, Chapin Hall, and RAND published the evaluations, including the null findings. Youth Villages licenses LifeSet and Intercept to partner agencies and helps states redesign their systems through New Allies.

Further Reading

Organization Sources

Independent Evaluations

Partner Agency Evidence (not counted toward the score)

Outside Coverage

REGULAR POSTS

Be the first to know when a new organization is certified—and why it meets the standard.

By signing up for our mailing list you will receive a quick email when we add a podcast or a new Fierce Certified organization. You'll also be the first to hear about events and workshops we may have from time to time. We won't share your information without your permission.

Great! Please check your inbox and click the confirmation link.
Sorry, something went wrong. Please try again.